Supreme Court Collegium 
Litigation News

Supreme Court seeks response from Centre on plea to bring Collegium decisions under RTI, finalise MoP on judges appointment

As per the plea, the existing MoP suffer from serious flaws due to lack of transparency and objectivity affecting the quality and performance of judges of the constitutional courts.

Ritu Yadav

The Supreme Court on Wednesday sought the response of the Central government and the secretary general of the top court to a plea seeking directions to the Chief Justice of India and the government to finalise the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) laying down the procedure for appointment of judges to High Courts and the Supreme Court

A bench of Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale issued notice to the government and the top court's administrative side on the plea which also sought directions to bring the Collegium decisions within the purview of the Right to Information Act (RTI Act).

Justice Sundresh initially expressed hesitancy in hearing the matter since he is part of the Collegium of the Supreme Court.

"Should we take this matter? Because I am also part of collegium," he said.

However, the petitioner's counsel said that he has no objections to the judge hearing the matter.

"Many of your lordships will be members of collegium. That objection will never go away," Senior Advocate Sanjay Hegde said on behalf of the petitioner.

"Then we will issue notice. The petition could have been drafted in better words," Justice Sundresh said.

"I completely agree," Hegde replied.

"Issue notice. Petitioner is permitted to file an amended petition," the Court said in its order.

The plea was filed by NGO Loka Prahari stating that appointment of judges to constitutional courts should be based on the unanimous view of the Collegium taking into consideration factors mentioned in the top court's 2015 judgment in NJAC case.

Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale of Supreme Court

The MoP was first drafted in June 1999 pursuant to the directions of the Supreme Court in the Second Judges case. It laid down the procedure to be followed under the Collegium system for appointing judges to the higher judiciary.

In 2015, the Parliament enacted the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) Act to mark a significant shift in the manner of the appointment of judges. The NJAC Act sought to replace the collegium system by providing for a body comprising representatives from both the judiciary and the Centre to make recommendations for the appointment of judges to the higher judiciary.

However, a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court, on October 16, 2015, struck down the NJAC as unconstitutional for violating independence of judiciary. Subsequently, for the first time ever, the Court invited suggestions for improving the Collegium system of appointing judges with the object of ensuring greater transparency in judicial appointments. Based on the inputs received, the Court on December 16, 2015 passed an order by which it left the task of amending the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) to the central government.

During the initial phase after the NJAC judgment, the MoP did not materialise due to disagreements between the Centre and the Collegium.

The disagreement between the two was pronounced during the tenure of former Chief Justice of India TS Thakur.

In March 2017, the Supreme Court unanimously rejected the recommendation of the Centre that they should have the power to reject any name for appointment as a judge of the high court for reasons of “national security”. Calls for a permanent secretariat to appoint judges were also rejected.

There were calls to take up the issue on the judicial side and this happened in October 2017 when a Bench of of justices AK Goel and UU Lalit decided to seek Centre’s response on the delay, stating in its order,

“…we need to consider the prayer that there should be no further delay in finalization of MOP in larger public interest. Even though no time limit was fixed by this Court for finalization of the MOP, the issue cannot linger on for indefinite period. The order of this Court is dated 16th December, 2015 and thus more than one year and ten months have already gone by.”

The order was passed in a petition by advocate RP Luthra but the case was subsequently pulled from that Bench and listed before a Bench headed by then CJI Dipak Misra who proceeded to recall the order passed by Justice Goel led Bench.

The new petition by Lok Prahari has now sought directions to the Chief Justice (on the administrative side) to make necessary changes to the MoP as mandated by the 2015 NJAC verdict.

The Central government's Ministry of Law and Justice should then finalise the MoP within a month after consultation with the CJI, the plea has sought.

As per the plea, the existing MoP suffer from serious flaws due to lack of transparency and objectivity affecting the quality and performance of judges of the constitutional courts and directly affecting the litigants' right to justice.

"Finalisation of the MoP for appointment of judges of constitutional courts at the earliest is necessary to ensure that it meets the requirement of the selection process ensuring that they possess four essential qualities of impartiality, fearlessness, transparency and purity mandated by the Constitution Bench in the case of Chief Election Commissioner and Election commissioners. This is evidently more necessary in the case of judges of Constitutional courts and especially, the Apex Court since their orders are final," the plea states.

Sanjay Hegde

When the plea was initially heard on November 2, Justice PS Narasimha had recused from the matter citing his appearance as an Additional Solicitor General in a similar case related to MoP.

The matter then came up before the bench headed by Justice Sundresh today when the Court proceeded to issue notice to the government.

Supreme Court dismisses plea seeking ban on animal sacrifice in temples

NLUO and CRY host round-table on Mental Health and Children in a Post-Pandemic World

PIL on police threatening lawyers: Delhi High Court seeks response from Manasavi Vashishta, MHA

Bombay High Court sets aside sanction to prosecute Chanda Kochhar in ICICI-Videocon bank loan case

"Heavens will not fall": Supreme Court refuses to stay interim bail to Azam Khan in ED case

SCROLL FOR NEXT