The Madhya Pradesh High Court recently pulled up the State government for citing a non-existent Supreme Court ruling in its reply to a petition challenging the dismissal of a police officer [Piyush Mani Tiwari vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh].
Justice Vivek Kumar Singh said the Court was constrained to take serious note of the "callous and irresponsible manner" in which the reply filed on behalf of the State was drafted.
The Court found that the judgment cited by the State was fictitious, while the citation provided corresponded to an actual ruling dealing with an entirely different subject matter.
"In their reply, the respondents have placed heavy reliance on a purported judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court titled ‘State of Andhra Pradesh vs. S.S. Mohammad Nisar’, cited as ‘(2008) 5 SCC 230’, to contend that re-appreciation of evidence is impermissible under Article 226. However, a bare perusal of the law reports reveals that no such judgment exists. The citation ‘(2008) 5 SCC 230’ actually corresponds to Sidhartha Vashisht @ Manu Sharma vs. State (NCT of Delhi), dealing with an entirely different subject matter regarding the suspension of sentence in a criminal appeal," the Bench said.
The Court noted that it was glaringly apparent that the State had blindly resorted to the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools to draft their pleadings, resulting in the incorporation of a fabricated case name cross-wired with an unrelated citation.
The judge stressed that the pleadings filed before a Constitutional Court are solemn documents, and strictly cautioned the State against what it termed "reckless practices."
"The casual insertion of fictitious case laws without undertaking the basic professional duty of cross-checking the citations not only wastes precious judicial time but also borders on actively misleading the Court," the Bench said.
The Court forwarded a copy of the judgment to the State Law Secretary and the Advocate General. It observed that the office of the Advocate General is expected to ensure that all legal propositions and citations are meticulously verified by the drafting counsel before they are sworn on affidavit and placed on the record of this Court.
Pleadings filed before a Constitutional Court are solemn documents. The casual insertion of fictitious case laws not only wastes precious judicial time but also borders on actively misleading the Court.Madhya Pradesh High Court
The Court made these observations while dealing with a petition filed by former police officer Piyush Mani Tiwari, who had been serving as an Acting Sub-Inspector at the State Situation Room, Special Branch, Police Headquarters, Bhopal at the time of his dismissal in 2024.
The State dismissed him from the service after a cleaner/sweeper accused him of behaving objectionably with her. Challenging the dismissal, Tiwari said the action was taken without conducting any preliminary or regular departmental enquiry.
The State defended its decision to dispense with a formal inquiry by invoking Article 311(1), read with Articles 311(2)(b) and 311(3) of the Constitution.
It said that the complaint involved a woman employee and prolonging the matter through an inquiry could cause distress and public outrage. Thus, it said that immediate action was needed to maintain public trust and discipline in the police force.
It also said that there was a likelihood of witness intimidation.
In the judgment passed on November 17, the Court said none of these grounds meet the constitutional threshold of Article 311(2)(b).
There was not a shred of material on record to show that the petitioner ever threatened, terrorized or intimidated the complainant or any witness or that an atmosphere of violence or insubordination prevailed which prevented witnesses from deposing, it observed.
Consequently, the Court set aside the dismissal and ordered the State to reinstate the police officer. However, the Court also granted the State a liberty to initiate and conduct a regular departmental enquiry.
Advocate Nityanand Mishra represented the petitioner.
Advocate Swati Aseem George represented the State.
[Read Judgment]