

The Delhi High Court on Thursday refused to entertain a plea by an Adivasi man from Chhattisgarh alleging that Christian families were forced to flee their village following threats and violence over their refusal to convert to Hinduism [Baman Ram Kawasi v Union of India & Anr].
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma held that the Chhattisgarh High Court was the appropriate forum to examine the matter.
The petitioner, Baman Ram Kawasi, had approached the High Court challenging the June 9 decision of the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) to dispose of his complaint by forwarding it to the District Magistrate (DM) and Superintendent of Police (SP) in Sukma, Chhattisgarh, with directions to take appropriate action within eight weeks.
In her judgment, Justice Sharma held that merely because the NHRC passed the order from its headquarters in Delhi, it would not confer territorial jurisdiction on the Delhi High Court to examine a challenge to the NHRC's decision.
"Even assuming that the passing of the impugned order at New Delhi gives rise to some part of the cause of action within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court, the same is not sufficient to warrant the exercise of writ jurisdiction by this Court, inasmuch as the petitioner, the victims, the place of incident, the authorities concerned and the entire relevant record are all situated in District Sukma, Chhattisgarh," the Court said.
According to the petition, Kawasi and other Adivasi families from village Chitlanar had been practising Christianity for around 18 years. On March 5, a mob allegedly entered their homes and demanded that they either convert to Hinduism or leave the village.
Two members of the community, Santa Barse and Ayte Barse, were allegedly assaulted with sticks and hospitalised. The families were also allegedly threatened with death and forced to leave the village. They have since been living in makeshift shelters in Sukma town.
The petitioner argued that the Delhi High Court had jurisdiction because the NHRC's decision was taken in Delhi.
However, the Union government opposed the plea, arguing that the alleged incidents, victims, local authorities and relevant records were all located in Chhattisgarh.
The High Court agreed, observing that the NHRC had merely acted as a channel by forwarding the complaint to the local authorities against whom the grievance was directed.
It said that examining the petitioner's prayers would require scrutiny of the incidents in Sukma, the alleged inaction of the local police and administration, and the subsequent action taken by them.
The Court further observed that accepting the petitioner's argument would mean that every NHRC order concerning an incident anywhere in the country could be challenged before the Delhi High Court merely because the Commission is headquartered in the national capital.
"In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is not inclined to entertain the present petition for want of territorial jurisdiction and on the principle of forum conveniens," the Court concluded and dismissed the plea.
It allowed the petitioner to approach the appropriate forum, including the Chhattisgarh High Court.
Advocates Jaiwant Patnakar and Philip John appeared for the petitioner.
The Union of India was represented through Central Government Standing Counsel (CGSC) Premtosh K Mishra as well as advocates Krish Bhatia and Vasu Agarwal.
[Read Judgement]