Bank of Baroda assures Bombay High Court it will preserve records in BR Shetty's $15B fraud suit

The bank opposed Shetty’s plea seeking disclosure claiming the suit is barred under Rule 89 of the Abu Dhabi Global Market Court Procedure Rules.
Bank of Baroda
Bank of Baroda
Published on: 
3 min read
Listen to this article

Bank of Baroda on Thursday assured the Bombay High Court that it will preserve all the documents sought by NMC Health founder Dr. Bavaguthu Raghuram Shetty in connection with his $15 billion damages suit against the public sector lender [Dr BR Shetty v. Bank of Baroda & Ors.]

Justice Arif S Doctor recorded the undertaking given by Senior Advocate Birendra Saraf appearing for the bank, after Shetty’s counsel pressed for interim protection of the records.

“He, however, assures the Court that all such documents forming part of the Schedule to the Interim Application and in the custody or control of Defendant No. 1 shall be preserved as they are. His statement is accepted,” the Court recorded on November 19.

Justice Arif Doctor
Justice Arif Doctor

Shetty in his suit has alleged fraud, collusion, negligence, and reputational loss by the bank and former NMC executives Prasanth and Promoth Manghat.

The suit claims Bank of Baroda closed anti-money-laundering alerts without inquiry and facilitated round-tripping after he stepped down as CEO in March 2017. 

Through his interim applications, he has sought forensic imaging of the bank's electronic systems, discovery on oath from the bank and ten officers, suspension of deletion policies, and $15 billion (around ₹1,43,700 crore) in security or balance-sheet provisioning.

The matter will next be heard on December 17. 

During the hearing on Thursday, Shetty’s counsel, Senior Advocate Zal Andhyarujina sought ad-interim disclosure of documents listed in the schedules to the interim application. 

He argued that if the Court was not inclined to grant disclosure at present stage, the bank could be directed to preserve the records so they are not tampered with.

Senior advocate Zal Andhyarujina
Senior advocate Zal Andhyarujina

Saraf opposed the relief contending that the documents already form part of proceedings before an Abu Dhabi court. He called Shetty’s apprehensions ‘wholly baseless’.  He however assured the Court to preserve the records in the bank's control.

Senior advocate Birendra Saraf
Senior advocate Birendra Saraf

Saraf also informed the Court that the bank had moved an application seeking deferment of the hearing. He referred to the Abu Dhabi court judgment holding Shetty complicit in the very fraud he alleged in his suit. 

He further argued that the cause of action arose in 2020 and that the suit is barred under Rule 89 of the Abu Dhabi Global Market (ADGM) Court of First Instance Court Procedure Rules, 2016. 

Andhyarujina disputed this. 

Andhyarujina appeared with advocates Waseem Pangarkar, Abhishek Gupta, Maithili Prabhu, Bhoomi Shah, Chinmay Bambarkar and Yash Sinha briefed by MZM Legal LLP.

Saraf appeared with advocates Robin Fernandes, Dharmendra Chatur, Aayush Shah, Adithya Nair and Harshit Bhimrajka briefed by Vesta Legal for Bank of Baroda. 

[Read Order]

Attachment
PDF
Dr. Bavaguthu Raghuram Shetty v. Bank of Baroda & Ors
Preview
Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com