Dispute over posthumous release of Siddhu Moose Wala's Phantom Ferrari song: Delhi HC refers case to mediation

Siddhu Moose Wala’s parents have opposed the release, arguing that their permission has not been taken for releasing the song.
Sidhu Moose Wala
Sidhu Moose Wala
Published on: 
3 min read

A dispute over whether music label Saga Music holds the rights to release the video of the "Phantom Ferrari" song sung by late singer Siddhu Moose Wala posthumously has been referred to mediation by the Delhi High Court.

Siddhu Moose Wala’s parents have opposed the song's release, arguing that their permission has not been taken for releasing the song.

Justice Manoj Jain heard the submissions made on behalf of the music label company and Moose Wala’s parents before referring the dispute to mediation.

Justice Manoj Jain
Justice Manoj Jain

Saga Music has filed a suit in the matter, alleging that a copyright assignment agreement was executed with Moose Wala in 2020, whereby his rights in the song 'Phantom Ferrari' were transferred to the music label. 

Saga Music uploaded a teaser on YouTube announcing that the full track would be released on November 13, 2026.

However, the father of the deceased artist threatened legal action and called for the take-down of the teaser and for the release of the song to be put on hold. He claimed on social media that the song was being released without Moose Wala's parents’ permission.

Saga Music eventually approached the High Court in the matter, seeking directions to restrain Moose Wala’s parents from preventing the release of the song. The music label has also sought damages. It claimed that the teaser of the song was removed from Saga Music's YouTube channel following representations made by Moose Wala’s parents.

Senior Advocate Akhil Sibal appeared for Saga Music before the High Court and argued that the song's copyright had been assigned to the music label, which Moose Wala's parents were aware of. Before his demise, Moose Wala had also announced that the song would be released by Saga Music, Sibal told the Court.

“There is an assignment agreement in my name. They [the parents] are fully aware of it. We have waited; he passed away in 2022. As a courtesy, we have been in touch with (the parents) (and informed them) that we have the right, give us your blesssing. I have already announced that I am releasing the video, the song has already been released. They are making defamatory statements that this is unauthorised... I have an assignment in perpetuity. It was assigned to me when he was alive. They have no legal right here. We have a legal right," he said.

He added that the song is a tribute to Moose Wala's memory and to his talent.

"We wanted to re-shoot the video. But then he was murdered. So we are now releasing the original video shot by him, featuring him," Sibal submitted.

The Court, meanwhile, urged the music label not to draw hasty conclusions against Moose Wale's parents over their opposition to the song's release.

“Let us not jump to the conclusion that they are wanting something. Let us not brand them as if they are extortionists. They might be just sentimental only," Justice Jain said.

Meanwhile, Moose Wale's parents argued that Saga Music's suit was not maintainable before the Delhi High Court. Their counsel also questioned the veracity of the copyright assignment agreement.

“Where is the payment? The parents do not know. Why would they pay me 5 lakhs more? How is it that there are two different agreements, two different signatures? The parents should be compensated if their son had executed the agreement.”

The Court urged the parents to try and settle the dispute with the music label in an amicable manner.

"Your son enjoys popularity sitting in heaven… It is better advised for both parties to find an amicable solution," it said.

The parents' counsel, in response, said that he had no objection if the matter is referred to mediation. He also assured the Court that the parents will not issue any further statements to aggravate the dispute for the timebeing.

With the consent of the parties, the Court proceeded to refer the dispute to mediation. The mediation process has been scheduled to begin on November 23.

The Court also asked Saga Music to produce the agreements it had entered into with Moose Wala.

The Court will hear the matter next on December 3.

Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com