

The Kerala High Court on Tuesday observed that the media should exercise restraint while reporting oral remarks made by judges during court proceedings, particularly when the circulation of such remarks could tarnish the image of lawyers or judges [TB Mini v The Hon'ble Registrar General & ors].
Justice PV Kunhikrishnan observed that judges and lawyers sometimes exchange jokes or make casual remarks during proceedings to ease the atmosphere in the courtroom.
However, such informal conversations should remain within the courtroom, the Court said while urging the media to restrain from reporting such exchanges in a manner that could damage the reputation of the judges or lawyers involved.
"Judges or lawyers may not intend any harm when they make comments or jokes in court, because a serious courtroom, where only interpretations of law and facts are discussed, can be boring for Judges, lawyers, and litigants, and a joke can ease the mood and atmosphere. Therefore, it is improper for the media to cover such dialogues between a lawyer and a Judge in a way that tarnishes the image of a lawyer or a Judge. The media should know what to neglect and what to project based on their journalistic experience in a sensible manner," the Court said.
Justice Kunhikrishanan observed that remarks made by judges may just be passing remarks, but their circulation by the media outside the courtroom could cause embarrassment not only to the judges, but also to the lawyers.
"Courtroom remarks by a presiding officer may be momentary, but their circulation may embarrass the person against whom they are made. Lawyers deserve dignity and fair treatment, and they should not leave the court, after arguing a case, feeling that the court insulted or humiliated them," the Judge said.
It also advised lawyers to not get influenced by social media discussions about courtroom remarks without understanding the context in which they were made. The Court urged lawyers to respond to such reports with professional solidarity, mutual respect and restraint.
"Equally, members of the Bar should not be carried away by social media reactions. In such situations, let us neither amplify a colleague’s embarrassment nor rush to hold the Bench in contempt without having the full picture and the context in which any remarks are made by the Judge," the Court said.
Justice Kunhikrishnan further addressed the responsibility of judges themselves in such matters.
He remarked that judges must be mindful of their oral remarks, particularly in the age of social media, while reiterating that journalists should exercise discretion in reporting courtroom exchanges.
"I am sure that the media, who always protect the democratic principles of the country, know what to report and what not to report, and they will always uphold those journalistic principles in future too. I leave it there," the Judge added.
The Court made the observation while dismissing a petition filed by advocate TB Mini seeking contempt of court action against trial judge Honey M Varghese over allegedly defamatory remarks made in open court.
The Court dismissed the plea after noting that advocate Mini did not personally witness the judge making the controversial remarks, and had only relied on media reports.
However, in its ruling, the Court also underscored the importance of ensuring mutual respect between judges and lawyers. Neither is above the other, the Court said.
"A lawyer's right to argue a case on behalf of his/her client before a court of law includes the right to receive fair treatment from the Bench. A judge decides a case based on the arguments raised by a lawyer. Judges and lawyers are officers of the court, and one is not above the other," the November 17 ruling reads.
Advocate Mini had represented the survivor in the 2017 actress assault case both in the trial court and the High Court.
Judge Varghese had conducted the trial and convicted the prime accused Pulsar Suni along with five others, while acquitting actor Dileep, who had been accused of masterminding the assault.
Advocate Mini had taken objection to certain remarks allegedly made by Judge Varghese about her (Mini) in open court in her absence. Terming the remarks scandalous, Mini had earlier approached the Chief Justice of the Kerala High Court with a complaint seeking contempt action against judge Varghese.
She subsequently approached the Advocate General (AG) of Kerala seeking sanction to initiate criminal contempt proceedings.
However, the AG rejected her request on April 22 this year.
Mini then approached the High Court with a fresh plea, stating that the AG failed to properly assess the materials placed before him.
She also argued that the judge's remarks were subsequently circulated by television channels and social media platforms, leading to abusive comments and attacks on her professional reputation.
The Court, however, dismissed her petition yesterday on finding insufficient material to establish the allegations against the judge.
Advocate K Nandini appeared for Mini.
Additional Advocate General PA Mohammed Shah appeared for the State.
Advocate Harikumar G appeared for the High Court's Registrar General.
[Read Judgment]