

The Karnataka High Court recently refused to quash criminal proceedings against former BJP MP Pratap Simha over a speech in which he questioned incidents of stone-pelting during Hindu religious processions and remarked that Hindus, who constitute 80 per cent of India's population, could also take to throwing stones.
Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde on October 8 held that the contents of Simha's speech, delivered at a public function in Shahapur, Yadgir district in September 2024, warranted investigation into allegations of provoking riots and deliberately outraging religious feelings.
The Court, however, quashed the proceedings against three persons who had organised the event, observing that there was no material to indicate that they had instigated Pratap Simha to make the alleged remarks.
Simha was the chief guest at the programme held on September 21, 2024, on the day of Ganesh idol immersion. The organisers had obtained permission to conduct the event.
According to the speech reproduced in the complaint, Simha questioned why stones were thrown at Hindu religious processions and challenged those responsible to show instances of Hindus pelting stones during Eid Milad processions. He went on to say that Hindus constituted 80 per cent of the country's population and questioned what would happen if they too took stones into their hands.
Referring to India's achievements in developing nuclear weapons, he questioned whether Hindus would be incapable of making petrol bombs. He also urged Hindus to set aside caste differences and unite, warning that the Hindu community could face dangers similar to those faced by Hindus in Bangladesh if they remained divided.
Following a complaint lodged on September 23, 2024, Shahapur police registered an FIR against Simha and the event organisers under Sections 192 (wantonly giving provocation with intent to cause riot) and 299 (deliberate and malicious acts intended to outrage religious feelings) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS).
Simha and the other accused approached the High Court seeking quashing of the FIR. They contended that the speech did not attract the alleged offences and that the police had also failed to follow the procedure prescribed under Section 173(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).
The State opposed the plea, arguing that Simha's speech was intended to disturb communal peace and outrage the religious feelings of a particular community.
The Court said that the question whether he intended to provoke rioting had to be examined during the investigation.
“From the contents of the complaint and from the contents of the speech more particularly, the Court is of the view that the matter requires investigation as against petitioner No.1. Whether the petitioner No.1 had intention to cause rioting has to be considered at the time of investigation,” the Court observed.
It noted that no rioting had actually taken place following the speech and, therefore, the first part of Section 192 of the BNS was not attracted.
However, the Court clarified that the second part of the provision could apply even if rioting did not take place.
“Whether the petitioner had a malicious intention to cause such riot requires investigation and based on the investigation the appropriate report has to be filed,” it said.
The Court also held that the complaint disclosed the basic ingredients of the offence under Section 299 of the BNS, warranting investigation against Simha.
Advocate Chaitanyakumar Chandriki appeared for the petitioners.
Additional State Public Prosecutor M V Anoop Kumar appeared for State.
[Read Judgment]