Supreme Court questions its registry after it fails to list ED appeal for hearing for 3 years

"This is nothing but institutional lethargy," the Court observed.
Enforcement Directorate  and Supreme Court
Enforcement Directorate and Supreme Court
Published on: 
3 min read
Listen to this article

The Supreme Court on Friday questioned why an appeal filed by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) in 2023 against the grant of anticipatory bail to a businessman remained without effective listing for nearly three years [Directorate of Enforcement v Raman Singhal @ Raman Singla].

A Bench of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana today expressed displeasure over this lapse.

“Why has this matter not been listed? September 2023, September 2024, September 2025, September 2026. This is what I want to know,” said CJI Kant.

When a lawyer suggested that Benches may not have been available, CJI Kant responded,

“All Benches are available.”

"This is nothing but institutional lethargy," added Justice Bagchi.

Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana
Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana

CJI Kant subsequently directed that the Court's Registry explain why the matter had not been listed in accordance with earlier directions.

The Court also declined to entertain the ED's appeal, after noting that the trial in the case had progressed substantially.

The ED's appeal arose from a January 30, 2023 order of the Punjab and Haryana High Court granting anticipatory bail to Singhal in a money laundering case. The case concerns an alleged ₹155.21-crore bank fraud involving Mahesh Timbers Private Limited.

The ED had alleged that the company fraudulently enhanced Foreign Letters of Credit (FLCs) and transferred the money obtained through these transactions to Amazon Exports Pte Ltd, a Singapore-based company of which Singhal was a director.

The agency alleged that the transactions caused a loss of ₹155.21 crore to the bank and named Singhal, along with other accused, in its money laundering prosecution.

Singhal was granted anticipatory bail by the Punjab and Haryana High Court in January 2023. The High Court took note of the fact that the ED had already filed its prosecution complaint and had stated that Singhal could not be arrested at that stage without a warrant from the trial court.

The ED challenged this order before the Supreme Court in May 2023, which issued notice in September 2023 and subsequently passed multiple orders directing the matter to be relisted, including for final hearing or disposal.

Despite those directions, the appeal remained pending for nearly three years without being taken up for effective hearing, prompting the Bench to question why it had not been listed.

Senior Advocate Siddharth Dave, appearing for Singhal, also expressed surprise at the delay, saying he had never seen such a situation in the Supreme Court.

Senior Advocate Siddhartha Dave
Senior Advocate Siddhartha Dave

Senior Advocate Zoheb Hossain, appearing for the ED, responded,

"Maybe, because you (Dave) have not been in the Supreme Court Registry."

Zoheb Hossain
Zoheb Hossain

Dave countered that he had been practising in the Supreme Court since 1990, adding that such delays did not ordinarily happen.

"Don't quibble with me about all these things. I am only saying these things don't happen," said Dave.

The Court, meanwhile, was also informed that the trial had commenced and eight witnesses had already been examined. Therefore, it declined to entertain the ED's appeal at this stage and disposed of the petition.

Hossain then requested that the impugned order not be treated as a precedent. Responding to this, the Court clarified,

“The impugned order shall neither be treated as a precedent nor shall have any impact on the outcome of the trial.”

[Read Live Coverage]

Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com