National Law University and Supreme Court 
Law School

NLU pressures student to withdraw post critical of Supreme Court NCERT ruling

The student has refused to take down his Substack blog post titled 'The Supreme Court of India has No Spine'.

Hiranya Bhandarkar

A law student from a National Law University (NLU) recently ran into trouble for having written a Substack post on the Supreme Court's decision to ban a chapter in the NCERT Class 8 textbook.

As per a redacted screenshot of the email shared by the law student, the Tamil Nadu National Law University (TN NLU) administration allegedly asked him to delete his post. The email stated,

"I am receiving a spate of phone calls from Advocates of the Supreme Court and various High Courts as well as a few Judges and Students of Law complaining and criticising your article posted in LinkedIn. The reputation of the Institution is at stake. Therefore, I request you to take down the article immediately in the best interest of the university and yourself."

Replying to the email from the administration, he refused to pull down his Substack post titled 'The Supreme Court of India has No Spine', stating,

"My opinions are mine alone. Any attempt to conflate them with that of the university is clearly wrong. It should be clear that the university has absolutely no jurisdiction over my personal expression. You do not own my voice or my conscience."

Speaking to Bar & Bench, the law student said that he did not receive any response from the University after his reply to the mail.

Substack Post

The Substack post in question criticised the conduct of the Bar, the language used by the Supreme Court and the judiciary with regards to the banning of the NCERT chapter.

The NCERT chapter on the role of the judiciary had two paragraphs titled 'Corruption in the Judiciary' which led to it being banned.

Shocking: Supreme Court summons IO and Police Commissioner over handling of Gurugram minor rape case

Protest against UGC draft rules: Delhi HC stays proceedings against Rahul Gandhi, Akhilesh Yadav and others

Malayalam actor Mohanlal moves Delhi High Court for protection of personality rights

Not every Section 498A case is moral turpitude: P&H High Court comes to aid of SBI branch manager who was fired

Make cabs wheelchair-friendly, consider dedicated vehicles for disabled persons: Supreme Court

SCROLL FOR NEXT