The Bombay High Court has directed automobile components manufacturer Bosch Limited to pay ₹25 lakh each to hundreds of temporary workers who were transferred from its Nashik plant to various locations across India [Bosch Vs NETW Kamgar Sangh].
Justice Sandeep V Marne held that the transfers did not adhere to the statutory procedure for retrenchment but were intended to discontinue the workers' services.
"The Petitioner No.1 is a large organisation and is expected to act as a model employer and not to indulge into unlawful methods such as initial implementation of Red-Light Activation concept and later by resorting to throwing out over 500 NETWs at far off places across the country to ensure that they are ultimately dismissed on account of non-joining at the transferred places," the Court observed.
In its November 19 judgment, the Court upheld the Nashik Industrial Court's finding of unfair labour practices but modified its direction requiring Bosch to reinstate the workers.
Instead, it directed Bosch to pay ₹25 lakh each to the workers covered by the dispute within six weeks, failing which the amount would attract 8 percent annual interest.
The dispute concerned New Entrant Temporary Workmen (NETWs) employed at Bosch's Nashik manufacturing facility.
Bosch claimed that stringent emission norms and the decision of major customers, including Maruti Suzuki and Honda, to discontinue diesel passenger cars had substantially reduced demand for diesel injectors.
The company initially introduced a system called 'Red-Light Activation', under which workers were prevented from reporting for duty whenever sufficient work was unavailable.
The workers challenged the arrangement and secured orders directing payment of wages even for days when work was not assigned. These orders were upheld up to the Supreme Court.
Bosch subsequently called the workers back in August 2024 but transferred them to different locations across India within weeks.
During the ensuing litigation, Bosch initiated disciplinary proceedings against workers who refused to report at their transferred locations. According to the union, 235 workers were eventually dismissed.
The High Court found that the transfers were intended to remove surplus workers rather than meet genuine business requirements.
"The real intention is to get rid of the workers and the tool of transfer is devised at achieving that objective," the Court said.
However, acknowledging the reduction in manufacturing activity, it declined to order reinstatement since doing so could prolong the dispute.
Bosch had earlier offered ₹14 lakh per worker and subsequently indicated its willingness to pay ₹18 lakh.
Considering the workers' length of service, statutory entitlements and Bosch's financial position, the Court fixed compensation at ₹25 lakh each as a full and final settlement.
Senior Advocates CU Singh and Kiran S Bapat along with advocates AD Patwardhan, CA Deolalkar and TR Yadav appeared for Bosch.
Advocate TK Prabhakaran represented NETW Kamgar Sangathana.
[Read Judgment]