Karnataka High Court  
Litigation News

Karnataka High Court refuses to stay curbs on sugar-based ethanol after government flags sugar crisis

The Court rejected a plea by an ethanol distillery and a sugarcane juice supplier to allow them to continue operations until their challenge to the validity of the recent ban on sugar-based ethanol production is decided.

Hiranya Bhandarkar

The Karnataka High Court recently denied interim relief to an ethanol distillery and a sugarcane juice supplier who have challenged an October 22 Central government order banning the diversion of sugarcane juice or B-heavy molasses towards the production of ethanol [Askins Biofuels Pvt Ltd & Anr v Union of India & Ors].

Justice CM Poonacha on November 17 rejected the petitioners' plea to allow them to continue operations until their petition challenging the validity of the Centre's order is decided.

The judge reasoned that the petitioners' commercial interests cannot be prioritised over the steps being taken by the government to tackle a sugar shortage in the nation.

"In view of the contention on behalf of the respondents (government) that the impugned orders dated 22.10.2026 have been passed having regard to the current situation whereunder there is a shortage of sugar, keeping in mind the estimates of the cane production for the year 2026-2027, the question of interdicting the impugned orders dated 22.10.2026 in any manner does not arise. The commercial activity of the petitioners cannot prevail over the impugned orders which have been issued due to the prevailing situation as noticed above," the Court said.

Justice CM Poonacha

The Court was hearing a plea filed by Askins Biofuels Private Limited, a standalone ethanol distillery, and Shri Bhramanandasagar Jaggery Industries, a jaggery manufacturer that proposed to supply sugarcane juice and sugarcane syrup to Askins, which could be used toward the production of sugar-based ethanol.

However, on October 22 this year, the Central government's Department of Food and Public Distribution issued an order to prohibit sugar mills or distilleries from producing ethanol from sugarcane juice and B-heavy molasses for the Ethanol Sugar Year 2026-27 (November 2026-October 2027).

The petitioners argued argued that the sugarcane used by them for ethanol production is from 5 per cent of the area allotted to farmers for sugarcane production, which is usually left to the farmers to deal with as per their discretion.

Sugarcane from 95 per cent of the area would still go toward sugar production, they pointed out.

They further highlighted that the Centre's October 22 order would bring their operations to a complete halt, and cause irreparable financial loss to the petitioners as well as workers employed at the ethanol production unit.

The Central government, represented by Additional Solicitor General, Arvind Kamath, countered that the October 22 order was necessary to tackle sugar scarcity. Any sugarcane used by the petitioners for the manufacture and production of ethanol would affect the sugar that is to be made available in the market, he highlighted.

K Aravind Kamath

He clarified that the October 22 order does not ban the production of ethanol from C-Heavy Molasses.

He also maintained that the government was well within its powers to pass the October 22 order under the Sugar (Control) Order, as amended in 2025, and Section 3 (powers to control production, supply, distribution, etc., of essential commodities) of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955.

He added that these measures are only interim arrangements that would be revised depending on further estimates of sugarcane production.

After considering these submissions, the Court declined to grant the petitioners any interim relief.

The Court clarified that the petitioners were free to make a representation before the concerned authorities to allow them relaxations as permissible in law.

The matter will be heard next on January 7, 2027.

Advocate Anirudha Ramchandra Nayak appeared for the petitioners.

[Read Order]

Askins Biofuel v UoI.pdf
Preview

Delhi High Court Women Lawyers Forum honours 52 women lawyers for legal aid and pro bono work

Related party under IBC- A paradox for financial creditors

All NHRC orders can't be challenged in Delhi merely because its headquarters are here: Delhi High Court

Order to clear highway encroachments not licence to bypass legal procedure: Supreme Court

People insensitive; police helpless: Bombay High Court slams public for flouting cracker restrictions during Diwali

SCROLL FOR NEXT