Mental Health, Karnataka High Court 
Litigation News

Police, security forces must periodically assess mental health of personnel: Karnataka High Court

"Personnel entrusted with protecting the lives and safety of others must themselves be provided care, support and reasonable assistance when they face personal or mental health difficulties," the Court said.

Hiranya Bhandarkar

The Karnataka High Court recently called for measures to be put in place to ensure the mental health and well-being officers of the police and personnel of other armed security forces, particularly before they are issued firearms [Jyoti Bai v State of Karnataka].

Justice Suraj Govindaraj held that the responsibility of a security organisation does not end merely by assigning duties to its personnel. Rather, it must take reasonable steps to look after the physical and mental well-being of its personnel.

"Personnel must have an environment in which they can seek assistance without stigma or fear of adverse consequences. Their need for counselling, treatment, family support, rest or temporary relief from particular duties must be recognised and addressed," the Court said.

Justice Suraj Govindraj

The Court went on to note that mental health is directly connected with operational readiness of personnel and public safety, particularly in the case of personnel entrusted with firearms.

It, therefore, called for mental health checks before firearms are issued to security personnel, and for periodic mental assessments thereafter.

"The authorities must have appropriate systems for assessing the mental health and fitness of such personnel, both before entrusting firearms and periodically thereafter, with provision for reassessment whenever circumstances so warrant," the November 12 order stated.

The Court also called for regulating access for personnel to firearms when genuince safety concerns exist, including about the mental well-being of the personnel

However, such measures should also not become a form of punishment or result in automatic exclusion from service, the Court added.

The Court made these observations while allowing a plea filed by a Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) Sub-Inspector (SI) to be discharged from a criminal case filed against her in 2022 (under the now-repealed Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code) for attempting to die by suicide using a firearm issued to her by the force.

Her counsel told the Court that she had been under severe mental stress due to her inability to conceive. She was also made to face disciplinary proceedings, following which she was imposed a major penalty of reduction of one stage of pay for her lifetime and denied promotions for five years.

The case led the Court to point out that personnel serving in security forces are also human beings, who experience grief, anxiety, financial problems and other personal difficulties.

The expectation that such personnel should be available at any time to perform their duties, regardless of their mental state or personal circumstances, requires a rethink, the Court added.

"Discipline and dedication are essential, but they cannot be demanded at the cost of ignoring the basic human needs of personnel," it said.

The Court ultimately set aside the trial court’s refusal to discharge the SI from the criminal case, holding that it had failed to consider the statutory presumption under Section 115 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017.

The provision presumes that a person who attempts suicide is under severe stress and should not be tried or punished under Section 309 of the IPC, unless the prosecution proves that there was no such distress.

"The legislative approach is to treat such a person as one in need of care, treatment and rehabilitation, rather than penal sanctions," the Court pointed out.

The Court further directed authorities to ensure mental health welfare measures were in place for armed forces personnel.

The Court said that the welfare of personnel and security of the forces could not be compromised. It called for setting up professional, accessible, and confidential mental health care to personnel serving in armed forces, police, and other security organisations.

"A force which looks after the mental and physical well being of its personnel is better equipped to maintain discipline, operational readiness and public safety," the Court pointed out.

The Court has also directed its Registry to forward a copy of this order to the Director General of the CISF and the Director General of Police in Karnataka, as well as the heads of other organisations in the State that had personnel entrusted with firearms.

Advocate Tarunn Surana appeared for the CISF Sub-Inspector.

High Court Government Pleaded Ranjith Kumar represented the State.

[Read Order]

Jyoti Bai v State of Karnataka.pdf
Preview

The meat of the matter

Penalising conduct once considered immoral will now amount to moral policing: Madras High Court

2025 Red Fort blast: Supreme Court transfers cases from J&K, Haryana to Delhi NIA court

Law doesn't guarantee that any particular constituency be reserved for SC/STs: Supreme Court

Supreme Court suspends sentence, grants bail to two convicts in Bilkis Bano gang rape case

SCROLL FOR NEXT