The Madras High Court on Friday advised government law officers against representing former Director of Public Libraries, Jayanthi, in contempt proceedings arising out of the alleged public libraries book procurement scam in Tamil Nadu.
A Division Bench of Justices GR Swaminathan and MD Sumathi made the remarks while hearing a contempt of court petition alleging wilful disobedience of a 2024 judgment prescribing safeguards for the procurement of books for public libraries.
“Let none of the law officers appear for Jayanthi. Please. Keep away. Keep away,” the Court remarked.
When Additional Advocate General PV Balasubramanian submitted that contempt was a matter between the Court and the contemnor and that he would leave it to the Court, the Bench reiterated its advice.
“Don't soil your hands by defending .... Law officers, keep away,” the Court said.
The contempt proceedings arose from alleged violations of a judgment passed on June 19, 2024 by a Division Bench of then High Court judge Justice R Mahadevan and Justice Swaminathan.
The judgment had directed the State government to adhere to its Transparent Book Procurement Policy. Among other safeguards, the Court had mandated the publication of shortlisted books on a dedicated website and provided for a one-month period during which members of the public could raise objections before the purchases were finalised.
However, allegations of large-scale irregularities in the procurement of books for public libraries surfaced earlier this month after Tamil writer Perumal Murugan flagged the issue on social media.
The controversy concerned the alleged procurement of plagiarised and artificially generated books, including those attributed to fictitious authors, using public funds.
On November 10, the High Court directed the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC) to register a first information report (FIR) and identify the officials responsible for the disputed procurements.
During Friday's hearing, Senior Advocate KPS Palanivel Rajan, appearing for the contempt petitioner, submitted that while the Court could not micromanage the administration in exercise of its contempt jurisdiction, those at the helm of affairs could not be allowed to go scot-free.
He argued that officials responsible for implementing the Court's earlier directions were bound to answer for their alleged breach.
The Bench found force in the submission and directed the issuance of statutory contempt notice.
The Court indicated that it would primarily focus on the roles of IAS officers Chandramohan and Jayanthi in the contempt proceedings, while also calling upon IAS officer Dr. M Aarthi to respond.
The Court also examined the composition of the High-Level Committee responsible for book procurement, including the role of former School Education Secretary Chandramohan, who chaired the committee.
It directed that all relevant files pertaining to the disputed procurements be placed before it.
Meanwhile, Additional Public Prosecutor Arun Anbumani informed the Bench that a separate criminal petition concerning the same subject matter was pending before the principal seat of the High Court in Chennai.
The Bench requested the judge holding the roster for cases against MPs and MLAs and DVAC corruption cases to monitor the investigation.
Additional Advocate General PV Balasubramanian informed the Court that the State government would consider the suggestions made by the Bench and issue a comprehensive policy governing the procurement of books for public libraries within eight weeks.
He assured the Court that the proposed policy would plug the loopholes that had surfaced during the proceedings.
Senior Advocate V Raghavachari, meanwhile, submitted that the Court's earlier directions calling for the suspension of officials had been misconstrued, resulting in action against innocent officials, including a chief librarian.
The Bench declined to examine the merits of individual suspensions but clarified that the affected officials could independently challenge such action and that their petitions would be considered without being influenced by its observations.
The matter will be heard again after four weeks.