Social media influencers, content creators and reel makers will not get the benefit of court order allowing journalists to cover protests unhindered, the Delhi Police has told the Supreme Court.
The Delhi Police made the submission in an affidavit filed in response to a batch of petitions concerning the recent Cockroach Janata Party (CJP) protests in the national capital, which called for the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gynanesh Kumar over alleged irregularities in the conduct of the special intensive revision (SIR) or electoral rolls.
During earlier hearings, the Supreme Court had warned the Delhi Police not to obstruct the media from covering the protests, amid complaints by journalists that they were being prevented from carrying out their work.
In its latest response, the Delhi Police has maintained that it has not knowingly obstructed any journalist from carrying out their duties.
"The Delhi Police has, at no point, sought to obstruct, impede or interfere with the bona fide discharge of journalistic duties, whether during the protests in question or otherwise," the affidavit said.
However, the police also maintained that there is a distinction between accredited journalists and "reel-makers" or content creators.
Content creators are not covered by the Supreme Court's earlier directive exempting media personnel from restrictions imposed by the Delhi police to regulate the movement of those present at the protest sites, the police argued.
As per the affidavit,
"The said direction protects journalists in the discharge of their professional duties and does not, and was not intended to, exempt the so-called reel-makers and social media influencers or unruly elements from the operation of the general law or from compliance with the lawful directions of the Law Enforcement Agencies at the site of a prohibited assembly."
The police added that the question of whether social media influencers and reel makers can be elevated to the status of journalists or reporters is yet to be determined.
"In the present era of evolving digital media, several individuals, whether creative or otherwise, make reels, upload them and commercially exploit the content created by them. While there can be no objection to such activities, the question as to whether such reel-makers can be elevated to the status of journalists or reporters is yet to be determined."
It further claimed that some protesters carrying cameras and microphones falsely identified themselves as journalists, creating difficulties in distinguishing reporters from "reel-makers."
“While there can be no objection to such activities, the question as to whether such reel-makers can be elevated to the status of journalists or reporters is yet to be determined,” the affidavit stated.
The police has urged the Court to examine the distinction between journalists who report facts neutrally and those who record events merely for content creation and subsequent.
"The predominant intent behind the activity may be the decisive factor (to determine whether someone is a journalist or a content creator)," it added.
However, the affidavit acknowledged that constitutional freedom to undertake lawful news gathering, recording, and publication extends to independent media persons, freelancers, citizens and individuals reporting through YouTube or other digital platforms.
This freedom cannot be denied solely on the ground that they do not possess PIB accreditation, an employer-issued press card, or employment with a recognised news organisation, it stated. Nevertheless, such content creators would be subject to the general law and to the lawful directions of the police, as is the case with every other citizen, the Delhi police said.
Notably, the affidavit also responded to specific allegations raised by individual journalists about police harassment they allegedly faced during the protests.
One such case concerns sexual harassment allegations made by three journalists against a police officer concerning an incident from October 3.
The affidavit said that two of these three journalists did not wish to pursue their complaints, while the third did not join police enquiries. The police added that after examining CCTV footage, not act of sexual harassment was detected.
"Thus, on the basis of the material presently available, the specific allegations could not be corroborated. Accordingly, the said three complaints have been filed and the matter stands closed," the police informed.
In another incident where Peek TV's reporters were reportedly dragged and detained, the affidavit said that a Deputy Commissioner of Police later met them and expressed regret.
"The said account itself demonstrates that the senior officers of the Delhi Police acted promptly to ensure that journalists, once identified, were not removed, and that any inconvenience caused in the midst of the crowd-control operation was not intentional," the affidavit added.
Another allegation was made by Ryan Thomas, a journalist at The Caravan, where he claimed that he was assaulted and detained by the police on October 11 has been denied by the police.
"He was merely removed from the site in exercise of the statutory powers vested in the police authorities, in the course of the ongoing crowd-control operation," the affidavit said.
In response to a report that a reporter with The Hindu was detained, the affidavit said that she was released as soon as the police recognised that she was a journalist. Similarly, the police points out that even by their own account, three Indian Express reporters were released 45 minutes later after their credentials were recognised.
The police also denied allegations that they illegally detained journalist Paranjoy Guha Thakurta.
"According to his own statement, (he) was not taken to any police station, but (he) states that the car in which he was placed 'was driven around for around 20 minutes and then released at a point half a kilometer away', and that he 'was released at approximately 1.00 pm'," the affidavit said.
The police also countered allegations that Shyam Meera Singh was illegally obstructed (an incident cited in the petitions before Supreme Court) by questioning whether he was a journalist or a participant in the protests.
"Mr. Shyam Meera Singh admits in his own statement that, in the midst of a confrontation between groups at Connaught Place and while being a part of an illegal protest, he was shouting slogans, which a journalist would never indulge in. He further states that upon reaching the police station, 'That's when I tried to escape from illegal detention.' These statements, on his own account, indicate his active participation in the events unfolding at the site, rather than the mere presence of a 'journalist' in the course of reporting them."
The police further denied allegations of having seized any camera or equipment from any journalist.
"It is submitted that no material or article was seized from any journalist. The articles seized from other persons were seized in exercise of statutory powers and included items found lying unclaimed, such as mobile phones, etc," the affidavit said, while urging the Court to dismiss the petitions before it.
The petitions before the Court include those by the Network of Women in Media, India, Free Speech Collective, Delhi Union of Journalists and Kerala Union of Working Journalists which flag concerns about the Delhi Police's response to journalists covering the Delhi anti-CEC protests.
The petitioners had referred to the Supreme Court October 11 order which said that lawyers, journalists and other professionals shall not be hindered in discharge of their professional duties.
The petitioners have claimed that the actions by the police amounted to violation of the said order.