Delhi High Court Justice Manmeet Pritam Singh Arora urged law firms not to stop recruiting fresh law graduates to save costs amid the growing use of artificial intelligence (AI), warning that the legal profession cannot afford to stop training its next generation of lawyers.
Speaking at the first meeting of the Indian Commercial Litigators' Forum (CLF), hosted by JSA Advocates and Solicitors in New Delhi on November 20, Justice Arora asked:
"We can't have a system where we only take on people after they have gained experience for three years. Who's going to train them for three years?"
Justice Arora said that she had heard that some law firms in India had stopped hiring A0 associates, even as concerns grow over the potential impact of AI on employment opportunities for young lawyers.
"While you are saving costs, please don't cut down on our future, because if today you will not take in A0 associates, you will not have yourselves tomorrow," she said.
Responding to her observation, JSA Managing Partner Amar Gupta said that firms were conscious of the need to retain training opportunities for fresh graduates even as the firm integrates AI into its operations.
“So what we have in mind is to reserve some kind of work entirely without any AI aid or assistance. And that's the first-level training that we will continue to impart to our new associates who come into our firm. And that roadmap is quite clear in our minds. We have onboarded AI models and we are doing it deliberately, with some method and planning,” Gupta said.
Justice Robin Knowles of the High Court of England and Wales moderated the session virtually from London. He emphasised the value of bringing insights from both the judiciary and legal practitioners to the upcoming seventh full meeting of the Standing International Forum of Commercial Courts (SIFOCC).
Delhi High Court Justice Prathiba M Singh shared global figures from a recent WIPO IP Judges Forum survey in Geneva covering 146 courts and tribunals. The survey stated that 35% of courts worldwide already have AI policies in place, 19 courts reported that 30% of their drafting involves AI, and an on-the-spot poll revealed that 52% of judges want to use AI for drafting.
Delhi High Court Justice Anish Dayal, who is leading the Indian judiciary's input on SIFOCC's AI workstream ahead of the seventh meeting in Zambia, pointed to the Supreme Court of India’s draft AI regulations alongside existing guidance from the High Courts of Kerala and Gujarat. Justice Dayal highlighted the need to guard against hallucinations and confidentiality breaches, while identifying where human decision-making remains irreplaceable. He also advocated for peer-to-peer judicial training and standardised operating procedures.
Justice Prateek Jalan welcomed CLF India and encouraged the forum to eventually expand its membership to include individual and small-firm practitioners who form a vital part of the Indian bar.