Aadhaar card not conclusive proof of date of birth: Delhi High Court

The Court upheld a labour court’s decision to give an employee the benefit of having her age calculated based on the date of birth in EPIC records instead of Aadhaar.
Aadhar
Aadhar
Published on: 
2 min read
Listen to this article

The Delhi High Court recently held that an Aadhaar card by itself is not proof of a person’s date of birth [M/s J. J. Electronics  vs. Smt. Rosamma Joy].

Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri made the observation while hearing a petition filed by JJ Electronics against a labour court order holding that an employee's date of birth mentioned in the Aadhaar card cannot be relied upon as conclusive proof.

“An Aadhaar card is not, by itself, proof of date of birth,” the Court stated.

Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri
Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri

The employee, Rosamma Joy, who working as a “Finishing Man‟, was terminated from service a year before her retirement, after JJ Electronics found discrepancy in her date of birth in her Aadhaar card and information submitted to Employees’ State Insurance Corporation (ESIC).

JJ Electronics claimed that Joy’s date of birth was 1959 in the Aadhaar card and 1960 in the ESIC information.

The management held that as per the Aadhaar card, she had attained the age of superannuation and consequently, terminated her service. Joy moved the labour court seeking reinstatement with full back wages.

The labour court did not rely on the Aadhaar card as evidence of Joy’s age since no witness from the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) was examined to prove the basis of the date of birth. 

Thereby, it held Joy’s date of birth as 1960 as mentioned in the EPIC records and awarded Joy back wages and consequential benefits. The company then moved the High Court against the same.

The High Court agreed with the labour court’s decision of relying on ESIC records for determining Joy’s date of birth.

“This is a finding of fact based on evidence. This Court is of the considered opinion that the same is a plausible view and cannot be termed perverse so as to warrant interference under this Court’s writ jurisdiction,” it stated.

It held that the Joy was illegally retrenched from services without complying with with the requirements under Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 which lays down mandatory conditions for retrenchment of employees.

“Once the workwoman was held not to have attained the age of superannuation, and the management failed to prove her resignation or voluntary retirement, the termination of her services without compliance with Section 25F of the ID Act was rightly held to be illegal,” the Court stated.

The Court further held that after the company recorded Joy’s date of birth in 1960, the management could not later rely upon a different date in an Aadhaar card to terminate her from service a year earlier. 

Hence, it upheld the labour court order and directed the company to pay Joy back wages within four weeks from the date of the judgment.

Advocates Renu, Kamlesh Kumar Mishra, Piyush and Mansi appeared for JJ Electronics.

Advocates Aarlin Moncy and Sruti Mehrotra appeared for Joy.

[Read Judgment]

Attachment
PDF
M_s. JJ Electronics v. Smt Rosamma Joy
Preview
Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com