

The Calcutta High Court recently set aside a trial court's decision to discharge Jyoti Ranjan Kanungo, the Chief Manager and Relationship Manager at a branch of the State Bank of India (SBI), from a case involving the alleged misappropriation of funds amounting to over ₹164.99 crores [Central Bureau of Investigation v. Shri Jyoti Ranjan Kanungo].
Justice Uday Kumar observed that there were strong allegations that Kanungo abused his official position, which warranted a full trial.
"They (evidence) establish a strong and grave suspicion of active complicity, criminal conspiracy, cheating, and abuse of official position against the Opposite Party (Kanungo) under Section 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988."
The Court further said that the order by the trial court suffered from gross illegalities. Justice Kumar noted that the trial court had conducted an impermisible "mini-trial" while deciding on Kanungo's discharge application.
"It is transparently clear that the learned trial court's adjudication suffers from foundational legal infirmities, a perversity of approach in evaluating defence explanations at the pre-charge stage, a complete omission to consider substantive incriminating materials, and an unsustainable legal anomaly that severs the insider public servant from the overarching criminal conspiracy involving private borrowers," the High Court held.
The Court concluded that the discharge order was patently perverse and sufferred from gross illegalities. It, therefore, set aside Kanungo's discharge from the case and directed the trial court to frame charges against him.
"The matter is remanded back to the learned trial court with a direction to restore Special (CBI) Case No. 02/22 to its original file qua the Opposite Party (A-3) (Kanungo)...the learned trial court shall proceed forthwith to frame formal charges against the Opposite Party (A-3) (Kanungo) under the appropriate provisions of the Indian Penal Code and the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, and conduct the trial jointly along with the remaining co-accused persons," the Court's November 12 order said.
The Court passed the ruling on a revision application filed by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) questioning the correctness of the trial court's decision to discharge Kanungo from the case.
The case involves allegations that public money was siphoned off from the SBI through unauthorised accounts, unbacked intercompany fund shuffles and signed monthly reports that actively concealed huge amounts of overdue of money.
The CBI has alleged that Kanungo aided a company named M/s. Shree Mahalaxmi Corporation Private Limited (SMCPL) in fraudulently securing massive credit facilities from SBI, which amounted to a loss of over ₹164.99 crores to the bank.
Before the High Court, the CBI's Special Public Prosecutor Amajit De referred to documentary evidence, audit trails and logs.
He argued that the financial discrepancies noted in these materials were not merely the result of routine administrative lapses but a clear sign that Kanungo acted as an active, conscious internal facilitator of a multi-crore public banking fraud.
Kanungo's counsel countered that he had no pre-existing link or motive to conspire with the accused company. All credit appraisals and restructuring proposals processed by him were strictly in line with institutional guidelines, being supervised and countersigned by several senior executives at the bank, including the Deputy General Manager, Kanungo's counsel added.
The Court, however, found that the trial court's decision to close the case against Kanungo reflected judicial overreach. Justice Kumar explained that the trial court had erred in weighing witness statements, interpreting internal audit nuances, and evaluating the evidentiary worth of departmental warnings at a pre-trial stage.
"This Court has conclusively established that the learned trial court committed a fundamental jurisdictional error by embarking upon a premature, exhaustive marshalling and sifting of evidence at the threshold stage of Section 239 CrPC," the Court observed.
It, therefore, set aside the discharge order and restored the case against Kanungo.
Kanungo was represented by advocates Aritra Bhattacharya, Saptarshi Basu and Suman Dutta.
[Read Order]