No religious angle in reassignment of cases; CJI Surya Kant considering more such moves

The matters so identified will then be reassigned and listed strictly as per the roster.
CJI Surya Kant
CJI Surya Kant
Published on: 
3 min read

Close on the heels of the reassignment of two cases from the bench of Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah, Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant is considering reassigning more such cases that were filed and listed as ordinary cases across benches, but have since been treated as public interest litigation (PILs).

The CJI has now asked the registry of the top court to identify all such matters and submit a report to him, sources informed Bar & Bench. The matters so identified will then be reassigned and listed strictly as per the roster.

The reassignment of cases from Justice Amanullah's Bench was an unusual move. That Bench had widened a student's dispute with a private university and a building dispute from Chennai into nationwide proceedings. Both the cases now stand reassigned since Justice Amanullah's bench does not have PIL jurisdiction.

Pertinently, Bar & Bench has learnt that the reassignment of the two cases was not linked to any religious sensitivity. Times of India had reported that the Chief Justice moved a matter that involved removal of stray cattle out of Justice Amanullah's Bench to avert a religious controversy. However, the Chief Justice was unaware of any such matter before Justice Amanullah's Bench until he read about it in a newspaper on Thursday.

Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah
Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah

Full court meeting and the reassignment

The issue of benches converting matters to PILs was flagged by the CJI more than a month ago, during a full court discussion, Bar & Bench has learnt.

At the meeting, the CJI informed the judges that matters are filed in the Supreme Court as ordinary cases and are listed automatically as per the roster. When a bench converts such a matter into a PIL, the Chief Justice learns of it only through media reports.

As per the Supreme Court Rules and a five-judge Constitution Bench ruling, if a bench believes a matter raises a larger public interest, it must refer the same to the Chief Justice, who, as master of the roster ,decides which bench hears it.

The CJI stated this at the meeting; he was backed by several senior judges and no judge opposed the view.

Interestingly, Bar & Bench learnt that the Chief Justice raised the issue only before the full court and did not speak to Justice Amanullah or any other judge individually. The Chief Justice then waited for the concerned benches to refer the matters to him on their own. That did not happen, prompting him to act.

In the meantime, the CJI also began receiving complaints from the Bar and from litigants. The complaints alleged misuse of power, not corruption. They said that disputes concerning individuals were often being enlarged in scope by various benches, resulting in authorities and officers being harassed and State governments being drawn into proceedings before the Court.

It was after this that the Chief Justice passed the order reassigning the matters and issued a circular to the registry.

The reassignment was based solely on the roster and not on any concern about the nature of the directions issued by the benches hearing the matter.

Bar and Bench - Indian Legal news
www.barandbench.com