The Delhi High Court on Friday held that merely because a person is residing in Delhi or able to access judicial orders online from the national capital on the internet does not confer territorial jurisdiction on the Delhi High Court.
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma noted that the petitioner wanted de-indexing of an order passed by the Gauhati High Court in a criminal case.
“The mere facts that the petitioner resides in Delhi or that the bail order in question is accessible on the internet from Delhi cannot confer territorial jurisdiction upon this Court, when the order sought to be de-indexed has been passed by the High Court of Gauhati, and the entire criminal proceedings, from the registration of the FIR till the discharge of the petitioner, have taken place within the State of Assam. Even otherwise, this Court is of the view that the High Court of Gauhati is the forum conveniens for adjudication of the grievance raised by the petitioner,” the Court observed.
The petitioner had sought directions to Google and Indian Kanoon to remove a 2019 bail order from name-based search results associated with his name.
An FIR was registered against him in September 2019 in Assam under Sections 493 (cohabitation caused by a man deceitfully inducing a belief of lawful marriage), 496 (fraudulent or mock marriage ceremony) and 376 (rape) of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). He was arrested the following day and granted bail by the Gauhati High Court on September 27, 2019.
A chargesheet was subsequently filed against him only under Section 498A (dowry harassment) of the IPC. However, a trial court discharged him on January 8, 2021, holding that the charge against him was groundless. The discharge order was not challenged.
He argued that the bail order continued to appear whenever his name was searched on Google, adversely affecting his reputation despite his subsequent discharge.
The Court said that accepting online accessibility as a ground for territorial jurisdiction would mean that every High Court in the country could entertain petitions seeking de-indexing of judicial records passed by any other High Court, irrespective of where the proceedings took place.
“Such an interpretation would render the requirement of the cause of action arising “wholly or in part” within the territories of a High Court under Article 226(2) of the Constitution otiose, and would also encourage forum shopping,” the Court said.
Ultimately, the Court rejected Tuli’s plea on the ground of lack of territorial jurisdiction.
Advocates Rudra Deosthali, Gautam Swarup and Sakshi Pandey appeared for the petitioner.
Advocates Amrita Prakash, Siddharth Srivastava and Shivam Sharma appeared for the Union of India.
Advocates Apar Gupta, Pragya Jain, Naman Kumar, Sahil Mander and Rahul represented IndianKanoon.
[Read Judgment]