Gauhati High Court 
Litigation News

Social media pictures of wife enjoying life can't prove ability to maintain herself: Gauhati High Court

The Court directed the woman's husband to pay her ₹2,000 per month despite her earning ₹7,500 from her employment.

Arna Chatterjee

The Gauhati High Court recently held that a wife's social media posts showing her enjoying life cannot, by themselves, establish that she is financially independent or capable of maintaining herself.

A Division Bench of Justices Michael Zothankhuma and Sanjeev Kumar Sharma made the observation while setting aside a family court order that had denied a woman maintenance from her husband.

The family court had denied maintenance after noting that the woman had uploaded social media posts showing her "enjoyful life at Guwahati". It had questioned how she was financing her lifestyle and observed that she was an able-bodied woman who could find employment to support herself.

Disagreeing with this reasoning, the High Court said,

"The finding of the learned Family Court that the petitioner-wife is having an 'enjoyable life at Guwahati' as uploaded by her on social media does not, in our view, prove that the petitioner-wife was able to finance her lifestyle through employment," said the Court.

The case arose from a marriage solemnised in March 2023. The couple separated approximately three months later. The wife had approached the family court seeking maintenance of ₹15,000 per month. She contended that although she had previously worked as a sales promoter, she was no longer employed and was living with her parents.

The husband opposed the plea, arguing that she was employed and earning a monthly salary. He also disputed her claims about his income and financial assets.

The High Court found that the wife did in fact working as a sales promoter with an agency and earned ₹7,500 per month. The husband's affidavit of assets and liabilities showed that he earned approximately ₹14,000 as salary.

However, the Court assessed his income from all sources at ₹18,000 per month, noting that he had not adequately explained his loan repayments or the income from a shop he reportedly owned.

"The petitioner though being able to maintain herself to a certain degree, is entitled to some more maintenance on account of the fact that she should be entitled to the same lifestyle she had been accustomed to, prior to her separation," it said.

Additionally, the Court also found no material to establish that the wife had refused to resume matrimonial life with her husband. It noted that neither party had filed for divorce and that the husband had not approached the court seeking restitution of conjugal rights.

The Court ultimately directed the husband to pay ₹2,000 per month as maintenance to his wife from November 2026.

Advocate D Pathak appeared on behalf of the wife.

Advocate S Paul represented the husband.

[Read Order]

X v Y.pdf
Preview

Karnataka High Court quashes case against MedPlus over short supply of one tablet costing ₹1.12

Kerala High Court quashes disproportionate assets case against minister KM Shaji

Aadhaar card not conclusive proof of date of birth: Delhi High Court

Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas tops RISE Legal India 2026 rankings; Khaitan & Co wins two awards

Allahabad High Court cautions against use of Gangsters Act against company employees for business-related offences

SCROLL FOR NEXT