Senior Advocate Darius Khambata 
News

Senior Advocate Darius Khambata hits back at Tata Trusts vice-chairpersons over listing u-turn

According to Khambata, Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh were earlier against the public listing of Tata Sons and Tata Trusts, but later changed their minds without reasons.

Neha Joshi

Senior Advocate and former Tata Trusts trustee Darius J Khambata has rebutted allegations levelled against him by Tata Trusts Vice-Chairmen Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh and questioned their sudden shift in stance on the public listing of Tata Sons.

In a four-page letter dated November 17, Khambata categorically rejected the personal attacks against him.

“I categorically reject the accusations you make against me in your letter. They selectively cite events excluding critical facts to construct a false narrative," he said. 

The exchange follows Khambata’s decision earlier this month not to seek reappointment as a trustee. In a November 2 letter to Chairman Noel Tata and CEO Siddharth Sharma, he had warned that the Tata Group's governance model was under threat over the proposed listing of Tata Sons. He had also criticised the events of the September 17 board meeting as “a day that will live in infamy".

In his latest communication, Khambata expressed disappointment that Srinivasan and Singh's November 13 letter failed to explain their change in position as regards the proposed public listing of the company. According to Khambata, the two were earlier against the listing of Tata Sons and Tata Trusts but later changed their minds without offering any explanation.

“I was disappointed and pained to see your letter of 13 November, addressed to me and sent to the Trusts but, strangely, not to me. Disappointed, because you still give no reason for changing your minds on listing in April 2026, after supporting the anti-listing stand of both Tata Sons and Tata Trusts in March 2024, May 2025 and July 2025," Khambata wrote. 

The senior lawyer also claimed that there was no debate on the listing question.

"The merits or demerits of listing is a debate that should be had at a Trust meeting not in correspondence. That is precisely the debate you did not initiate – the correct course rather than going to the media."

On accusations regarding Tata Sons Chairman N Chandrasekaran's third term, Khambata clarified that his November 2 letter concerned the board's conduct on September 17 rather than Chandrasekaran's performance. 

He pointed out that after Chandrasekaran announced on August 12 that he would not seek reappointment, all trustees (including Srinivasan and Singh) agreed the next day to respect his wishes and form a selection committee.

Khambata also dismissed suggestions that he had strategised to ‘temporarily oust’ Srinivasan as a trustee in October 2025 to alter the Trusts' constitution.

“Had I been acting as part of any strategy, I would not have voted to reappoint Venu both in October 2025 and on November 11, 2025, when my one vote could have easily blocked his reappointment," he noted. 

He added that Singh had proposed Bhaskar Bhatt's appointment at the very same November 11 meeting where Khambata proposed Neville Tata.

On the legal front, Khambata contested their reading of the Supreme Court's 2021 ruling in Tata Consultancy Services v. Cyrus Investments Pvt Ltd. He maintained that Tata Trusts' control over Tata Sons is a fiduciary duty to protect its primary asset and does not jeopardise the Trusts' tax-exempt status. 

“You mischaracterize my defence of the ‘Tata Model’ as ‘control of Tata Sons’ by the present leadership of the Tata Trusts. It is control of Tata Sons by the Tata Trusts that is of the essence of the Tata Model; that is not an end in itself but is a discharge of the fiduciary duty each Trustee owes to protect the main asset of the Trusts viz. its shareholding in Tata Sons. This does not affect the tax exempt status of the Trusts,” the former Trustee said. 

Despite the rebuttal, Khambata welcomed their call for a resolution.

“It is my fervent desire that these disputes of personality and approach be resolved and I would think your role as Vice – Chairmen is better served to bring about such resolution in the larger interests of Tata Sons, Tata Trusts, the past and present employees of the Tata Group and indeed of our nation,” he concluded.

Kerala High Court asks media to be cautious while reporting oral remarks made by judges in court

Calcutta High Court upholds death penalty of man for rape and murder of 5-year-old girl

Karnataka High Court stays probe against 10 more persons accused of attempting to delete Muslim voters through Form 7

Sunny Deol's Suryaa movie will carry disclaimer that it is fictional: Producers to Delhi High Court

Non-Jains cannot claim bonafide use of Jain deity names as trademark: Madras High Court

SCROLL FOR NEXT