The Supreme Court on Friday allowed the remission plea filed by Rohit Chaturvedi, a convict in the 2003 Madhumita Shukla murder case. [Rohit Chaturvedi v. State of Uttarakhand].A Bench of Justices BV Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan held that the Ministry of Home Affairs’ communication dated July 9, 2025, rejecting the recommendation of the Uttarakhand government for Chaturvedi’s premature release, was legally unsustainable."We have no hesitation in holding that the impugned letter dated 09.07.2025, whereby the recommendation of the State of Uttarakhand was rejected and the plea for premature release of the petitioner was disallowed, is arbitrary, non-speaking, and unsustainable in law as well as on merits, and is therefore liable to be set aside and quashed. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed," said the order..The Court also took note of Chaturvedi’s custody period and his present status and directed that he would not be required to return to custody.“Since he is already outside, do not surrender,” said the Court..Additionally, the Court also underscored the reformative objective of criminal justice while dealing with remission. Invoking the philosophy of Plato, the Court remarked, “We have quoted Plato, the Greek philosopher, with regard to remission, saying not to have retribution, but reformation."Elaborating on the distinction between punishment and reform, the Court said,"The man is in jail for 22 years, he wants to reform himself and come out, or he has reformed himself, we should give him an opportunity. Crime is one thing, reform is different.".The case traces back to the May 9, 2003 murder of poet Madhumita Shukla, who was shot dead at her residence in Lucknow while she was seven months pregnant. The investigation was later taken over by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). According to the agency, the murder was the outcome of a criminal conspiracy involving former UP Minister Amarmani Tripathi, his wife Madhumani Tripathi, Rohit Chaturvedi and others. The CBI alleged that Chaturvedi arranged the killing by hiring assailants to eliminate the poet.In 2007, a Dehradun trial court convicted Amarmani Tripathi, Madhumani Tripathi, Rohit Chaturvedi and Santosh Kumar Rai and sentenced them to life imprisonment. In 2012, the Uttarakhand High Court upheld the convictions. The Supreme Court had later affirmed the verdicts..The remission issue had been pending before the Supreme Court amid questions over which State government was competent to decide the plea after the trial had been transferred. In early 2025, another Bench of the top court had directed the Uttarakhand government and the Centre to take a decision on Chaturvedi’s plea within a fixed timeline..[Read Live Coverage]
